Petition · past parliament
Prevent Family Courts taking children from families without 95% evidence
Rejected
18 signatures
What the petition asks
Too many families are broken up without a sufficient percentage of evidence. Currently, during a fact finding hearing in a family court, they only need to be 51% sure of their findings to make a decision. I don't think that is a fair percentage to take children away from their families.
So many children have guardians to speak for them but they are not fighting to.compromise the child's wishes. Give children a voice.
Why it was rejected
It was not clear what the petition asked the UK Government or Parliament to do.
It's clear you are concerned about the standard of proof used in the family courts.
At the moment, the required standard of proof in the family courts is known as "the balance of probabilities" - we think this is what you mean by "51% evidence". The standard of proof in criminal cases is "Guilt beyond a reasonable doubt", which might be what you mean by "95% evidence".
If we have understood your petition correctly, you could consider starting a petition asking Parliament to change the law to raise the standard of proof in family law cases to the criminal standard.
If it is clear that you are also concerned about the way in which guardians are carrying out their role. You could ask the Government or Parliament to reconsider the role and duties of a guardian and whether any changes are needed.
At the moment, the required standard of proof in the family courts is known as "the balance of probabilities" - we think this is what you mean by "51% evidence". The standard of proof in criminal cases is "Guilt beyond a reasonable doubt", which might be what you mean by "95% evidence".
If we have understood your petition correctly, you could consider starting a petition asking Parliament to change the law to raise the standard of proof in family law cases to the criminal standard.
If it is clear that you are also concerned about the way in which guardians are carrying out their role. You could ask the Government or Parliament to reconsider the role and duties of a guardian and whether any changes are needed.
Timeline
| 5 Sep 2015 | Petition opened for signatures |
| 14 Oct 2015 | Rejected by the Petitions Committee |
Key facts
Signatures
18
Status
Rejected
Rejected
14 Oct 2015
Follow this petition
Sign in to get an email when the government responds, a debate is scheduled or held, or the petition closes.
Source: the official petition page. Last checked 15 Jul 2026.