Motion · S3M-05368 · 8 Dec 2009
The Proposed Extradition of Gary McKinnon to America
The motion
That the Parliament views with serious concern the proposed extradition to the United States of America of Glasgow-born Gary McKinnon, who has Asperger syndrome and who can best be described as a misguided or deluded hacker rather than a saboteur; believes that the Extradition Act 2003, which is being employed to send him to the USA, is manifestly unbalanced in that it denies both due process and equality of treatment; agrees with his mother, Janis Sharp, that “we do not have equal rights with Americans”; is of the view that, were Gary McKinnon to be sent to the USA to be imprisoned there, it is extremely doubtful that his human rights would be protected and his medical needs attended to in that country’s overcrowded and chronically under-funded prison system; notes the observation made by Lord Carlile, QC, that Gary McKinnon’s proposed extradition is disproportionate, unnecessary and avoidable, and therefore concludes that, if Gary McKinnon has to stand trial for offences that he is alleged to have committed, he should be tried in a court in the United Kingdom.
Supporters (30)
- Brian Adam 8 Dec 2009
- Jackie Baillie Scottish Labour 8 Dec 2009
- Helen Eadie 8 Dec 2009
- Ross Finnie 8 Dec 2009
- Robin Harper 8 Dec 2009
- Patrick Harvie Scottish Green Party 8 Dec 2009
- Bill Kidd 8 Dec 2009
- Stewart Maxwell 8 Dec 2009
- John Farquhar Munro 8 Dec 2009
- Hugh O'Donnell 8 Dec 2009
- Mike Pringle 8 Dec 2009
- Elaine Smith 8 Dec 2009
- Shirley-Anne Somerville Scottish National Party 8 Dec 2009
- Bill Wilson 8 Dec 2009
- Bill Butler 9 Dec 2009
- Hugh Henry 9 Dec 2009
- Jamie Hepburn Scottish National Party 9 Dec 2009
- Anne McLaughlin 9 Dec 2009
- Stuart McMillan Scottish National Party 9 Dec 2009
- Gil Paterson 9 Dec 2009
- Rhona Brankin 10 Dec 2009
- Robert Brown 10 Dec 2009
- Christina McKelvie 10 Dec 2009
- Elaine Murray 10 Dec 2009
- Sandra White 10 Dec 2009
- Linda Fabiani 16 Dec 2009
- Christine Grahame 16 Dec 2009
- Angela Constance Scottish National Party 17 Dec 2009
- Maureen Watt 7 Jan 2010
- Cathy Peattie 11 Jan 2010
Source: the Scottish Parliament motions and amendments record.