Motion · S1M-03510 · 28 Oct 2002
Royal National Institute for the Blind Campaign on Photodynamic Therapy Treatment
The motion
That the Parliament congratulates the Royal National Institute of the Blind, Scotland, on its campaign to secure the provision on the NHS of the effective Photodynamic Therapy Treatment (PDT) for wet Age-related Macular Degeneration; notes that the total cost of this treatment would be an estimated £2 million, equating to £6,000 per patient; further notes that the average cost of caring for someone who becomes blind is £10,000 per annum; rejects the unjustified rationing of the treatment in England and Wales proposed by the National Institute for Clinical Excellence (NICE) which would limit treatment to only the second affected eye and only if the second eye retains at least 6/36 acuity; further rejects the need to wait until the NICE appeal is completed before the treatment is available on the NHS in Scotland; calls on the Scottish Executive to fund forthwith PDT treatment by the NHS in Scotland, and believes that it is unacceptable that 600 elderly Scots who could benefit from the PDT treatment will otherwise unnecessarily go blind each year.
Supporters (42)
- Bill Butler 29 Oct 2002
- Roseanna Cunningham 29 Oct 2002
- Kenny MacAskill 29 Oct 2002
- Fiona McLeod 29 Oct 2002
- Alex Neil 29 Oct 2002
- John Scott 29 Oct 2002
- Stewart Stevenson 29 Oct 2002
- Brian Adam 30 Oct 2002
- Scott Barrie 30 Oct 2002
- Cathie Craigie 30 Oct 2002
- Helen Eadie 30 Oct 2002
- Dorothy-Grace Elder 30 Oct 2002
- Kenneth Gibson No Party Affiliation 30 Oct 2002
- Karen Gillon 30 Oct 2002
- Trish Godman 30 Oct 2002
- Donald Gorrie 30 Oct 2002
- Ken Macintosh 30 Oct 2002
- Maureen Macmillan 30 Oct 2002
- Michael Matheson 30 Oct 2002
- Michael McMahon 30 Oct 2002
- Mr Brian Monteith 30 Oct 2002
- Mary Scanlon 30 Oct 2002
- Nicola Sturgeon 30 Oct 2002
- Murray Tosh 30 Oct 2002
- Brian Fitzpatrick 31 Oct 2002
- Tom McCabe 31 Oct 2002
- Sandra White 31 Oct 2002
- Robin Harper 1 Nov 2002
- Dr Winnie Ewing 6 Nov 2002
- Dr Sylvia Jackson 6 Nov 2002
- Gil Paterson 7 Nov 2002
- Mr Lloyd Quinan 7 Nov 2002
- Adam Ingram 11 Nov 2002
- Angus MacKay 13 Nov 2002
- Irene McGugan 13 Nov 2002
- Ian Jenkins 14 Nov 2002
- Marilyn Livingstone 19 Nov 2002
- Fergus Ewing 22 Nov 2002
- Mrs Lyndsay McIntosh 22 Nov 2002
- Jamie Stone 26 Nov 2002
- Andrew Wilson 6 Dec 2002
- Elaine Smith 13 Dec 2002
Source: the Scottish Parliament motions and amendments record.