Motion · S3M-03235 · 15 Jan 2009
Appointment of Chair of the Board of the Scottish Qualifications Authority
The motion
That the Parliament notes the announcement by the Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning on Monday 12 January 2009 of the appointment of Councillor Graham Houston as chair of the Scottish Qualifications Authority (SQA); also notes that Councillor Houston also holds a high profile political position in a local authority and that in this role he will be called on to participate in national and local meetings where matters relating to national qualifications will be discussed; further notes that as chair of the SQA he will be called on to make decisions relating to individual schools and local authorities, including on charging policies and performance-related issues; expresses concern about the direct conflict of interest that occurs should one individual hold these two positions, this conflict arising regardless of the abilities, experience and party affiliation of the individual and which would be particularly inappropriate in the context of the management and delivery of examinations and qualifications, which should be independent of party politics, and calls on the Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning to recognise this direct conflict of interest and to review the appointment as a matter of urgency.
Supporters (35)
- Bill Butler 15 Jan 2009
- Patricia Ferguson 15 Jan 2009
- Ross Finnie 15 Jan 2009
- Hugh Henry 15 Jan 2009
- Mike Rumbles 15 Jan 2009
- Karen Whitefield 15 Jan 2009
- Richard Baker 16 Jan 2009
- Margaret Curran 16 Jan 2009
- Murdo Fraser Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party 16 Jan 2009
- Andy Kerr 16 Jan 2009
- Marilyn Livingstone 16 Jan 2009
- Jamie McGrigor 16 Jan 2009
- David McLetchie 16 Jan 2009
- Mary Mulligan 16 Jan 2009
- John Park 16 Jan 2009
- Mike Pringle 16 Jan 2009
- Mary Scanlon 16 Jan 2009
- Margaret Smith 16 Jan 2009
- Nicol Stephen 16 Jan 2009
- Jim Tolson 16 Jan 2009
- David Whitton 16 Jan 2009
- James Kelly 19 Jan 2009
- Liz Smith 19 Jan 2009
- Jackie Baillie Scottish Labour 20 Jan 2009
- Rhona Brankin 20 Jan 2009
- Robert Brown 20 Jan 2009
- Marlyn Glen 20 Jan 2009
- Ken Macintosh 20 Jan 2009
- Michael McMahon 20 Jan 2009
- Nanette Milne 20 Jan 2009
- Karen Gillon 28 Jan 2009
- Rhoda Grant 28 Jan 2009
- David Stewart 28 Jan 2009
- Peter Peacock 2 Feb 2009
- Dr Richard Simpson 2 Feb 2009
Source: the Scottish Parliament motions and amendments record.