Holyrood division · 23 Feb 2012, 00:00 · S4M-02084.4
Economy and Recovery
Defeated
Majority 48
For: 35
Against: 83
Abstain: 0
Turnout: 118 of 128 MSPs voted (92%) · 10 did not vote.
How the parties voted
For (35)
| Unknown | 30 |
| Scottish Labour | 4 |
| Scottish Green Party | 1 |
Against (83)
| Unknown | 70 |
| Scottish National Party | 10 |
| No Party Affiliation | 1 |
| Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party | 1 |
| Scottish Liberal Democrats | 1 |
Every vote
No members match your search.
For (35)
Patrick HarvieScottish Green Party · Glasgow (region)
Jackie BaillieScottish Labour · Dumbarton
Claire BakerScottish Labour · Mid Scotland and Fife (region)
Neil BibbyScottish Labour · West Scotland (region)
Mark GriffinScottish Labour · Central Scot and Lothians West (region)- Richard BakerUnknown
Sarah BoyackUnknown- Malcolm ChisholmUnknown
Kezia DugdaleUnknown- Helen EadieUnknown
- Mary FeeUnknown
- Patricia FergusonUnknown
- Neil FindlayUnknown
Rhoda GrantUnknown- Iain GrayUnknown
- Hugh HenryUnknown
Alison JohnstoneUnknown- James KellyUnknown
- Johann LamontUnknown
- Ken MacintoshUnknown
- Hanzala MalikUnknown
- Paul MartinUnknown
- Margaret McCullochUnknown
- Margaret McDougallUnknown
- Michael McMahonUnknown
- Siobhan McMahonUnknown
- Anne McTaggartUnknown
- Elaine MurrayUnknown
- John ParkUnknown
- Graeme PearsonUnknown
- John PentlandUnknown
- Dr Richard SimpsonUnknown
- Drew SmithUnknown
- Elaine SmithUnknown
- David StewartUnknown
Against (83)
Kenneth GibsonNo Party Affiliation · Cunninghame North
Murdo FraserScottish Conservative and Unionist Party · Mid Scotland and Fife (region)
Willie RennieScottish Liberal Democrats · Fife North East
George AdamScottish National Party · Paisley
Clare AdamsonScottish National Party · Motherwell and Wishaw
Colin BeattieScottish National Party · Midlothian North
Keith BrownScottish National Party · Clackmannanshire and Dunblane
Angela ConstanceScottish National Party · Almond Valley
Bob DorisScottish National Party · Glasgow Kelvin and Maryhill
Jamie HepburnScottish National Party · Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
Stuart McMillanScottish National Party · Inverclyde
John SwinneyScottish National Party · Perthshire North
David TorranceScottish National Party · Kirkcaldy- Brian AdamUnknown
Dr Alasdair AllanUnknown- Marco BiagiUnknown
- Chic BrodieUnknown
- Gavin BrownUnknown
- Margaret BurgessUnknown
- Aileen CampbellUnknown
- Roderick CampbellUnknown
Jackson CarlawUnknown
Willie CoffeyUnknown- Bruce CrawfordUnknown
- Ruth DavidsonUnknown
Graeme DeyUnknown- Nigel DonUnknown
James DornanUnknown- Jim EadieUnknown
Annabelle EwingUnknown- Linda FabianiUnknown
- Alex FergussonUnknown
- John FinnieUnknown
Joe FitzPatrickUnknown- Rob GibsonUnknown
- Annabel GoldieUnknown
Christine GrahameUnknown- Jim HumeUnknown
Fiona HyslopUnknown- Adam IngramUnknown
- Alex JohnstoneUnknown
- Colin KeirUnknown
Bill KiddUnknown- John LamontUnknown
Richard LochheadUnknown- Richard LyleUnknown
- Kenny MacAskillUnknown
- Angus MacDonaldUnknown
Gordon MacDonaldUnknown- Derek MackayUnknown
- Mike MacKenzieUnknown
John MasonUnknown- Stewart MaxwellUnknown
- Joan McAlpineUnknown
- Mark McDonaldUnknown
- Jamie McGrigorUnknown
- Alison McInnesUnknown
- Christina McKelvieUnknown
- Aileen McLeodUnknown
- David McLetchieUnknown
- Nanette MilneUnknown
- Margaret MitchellUnknown
- Alex NeilUnknown
- Gil PatersonUnknown
- Dennis RobertsonUnknown
Shona RobisonUnknown- Michael RussellUnknown
- Alex SalmondUnknown
- Mary ScanlonUnknown
- John ScottUnknown
- Tavish ScottUnknown
Liz SmithUnknown- Stewart StevensonUnknown
Kevin StewartUnknown
Nicola SturgeonUnknown- Dave ThompsonUnknown
- Jean UrquhartUnknown
- Bill WalkerUnknown
- Maureen WattUnknown
- Paul WheelhouseUnknown
- Sandra WhiteUnknown
- John WilsonUnknown
Humza YousafUnknown
Did not vote (10)
Liam McArthurScottish Liberal Democrats · Orkney Islands- Claudia BeamishUnknown
- Roseanna CunninghamUnknown
- Fergus EwingUnknown
- Lewis MacdonaldUnknown
- Margo MacDonaldUnknown
- Jenny MarraUnknown
Michael MathesonUnknown- Fiona McLeodUnknown
- Duncan McNeilUnknown
Source: the Scottish Parliament vote record.