Holyrood division · 4 Oct 2012, 00:00 · S4M-04365.3

Employability

Defeated

Majority 12

For: 50 Against: 62 Abstain: 0

Turnout: 112 of 128 MSPs voted (88%) · 16 did not vote.

How the parties voted

For (50)

Unknown	42
Scottish Labour	4
Scottish Liberal Democrats	2
Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party	1
Scottish Green Party	1

Against (62)

Unknown	51
Scottish National Party	10
No Party Affiliation	1

Every vote

For (50)

Murdo FraserScottish Conservative and Unionist Party · Mid Scotland and Fife (region)
Patrick HarvieScottish Green Party · Glasgow (region)
Jackie BaillieScottish Labour · Dumbarton
Claire BakerScottish Labour · Mid Scotland and Fife (region)
Neil BibbyScottish Labour · West Scotland (region)
Mark GriffinScottish Labour · Central Scot and Lothians West (region)
Liam McArthurScottish Liberal Democrats · Orkney Islands
Willie RennieScottish Liberal Democrats · Fife North East
Richard BakerUnknown
Claudia BeamishUnknown
Sarah BoyackUnknown
Gavin BrownUnknown
Jackson CarlawUnknown
Malcolm ChisholmUnknown
Ruth DavidsonUnknown
Mary FeeUnknown
Patricia FergusonUnknown
Neil FindlayUnknown
Rhoda GrantUnknown
Iain GrayUnknown
Hugh HenryUnknown
Jim HumeUnknown
Alex JohnstoneUnknown
Alison JohnstoneUnknown
James KellyUnknown
Johann LamontUnknown
John LamontUnknown
Lewis MacdonaldUnknown
Ken MacintoshUnknown
Jenny MarraUnknown
Paul MartinUnknown
Margaret McCullochUnknown
Margaret McDougallUnknown
Jamie McGrigorUnknown
Michael McMahonUnknown
Siobhan McMahonUnknown
Duncan McNeilUnknown
Anne McTaggartUnknown
Nanette MilneUnknown
Margaret MitchellUnknown
Elaine MurrayUnknown
John ParkUnknown
John PentlandUnknown
Mary ScanlonUnknown
John ScottUnknown
Dr Richard SimpsonUnknown
Drew SmithUnknown
Elaine SmithUnknown
Liz SmithUnknown
David StewartUnknown

Against (62)

Kenneth GibsonNo Party Affiliation · Cunninghame North
George AdamScottish National Party · Paisley
Clare AdamsonScottish National Party · Motherwell and Wishaw
Colin BeattieScottish National Party · Midlothian North
Keith BrownScottish National Party · Clackmannanshire and Dunblane
Angela ConstanceScottish National Party · Almond Valley
Bob DorisScottish National Party · Glasgow Kelvin and Maryhill
Jamie HepburnScottish National Party · Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
Stuart McMillanScottish National Party · Inverclyde
John SwinneyScottish National Party · Perthshire North
David TorranceScottish National Party · Kirkcaldy
Brian AdamUnknown
Dr Alasdair AllanUnknown
Marco BiagiUnknown
Chic BrodieUnknown
Aileen CampbellUnknown
Roderick CampbellUnknown
Willie CoffeyUnknown
Bruce CrawfordUnknown
Roseanna CunninghamUnknown
Graeme DeyUnknown
James DornanUnknown
Jim EadieUnknown
Annabelle EwingUnknown
Fergus EwingUnknown
Linda FabianiUnknown
John FinnieUnknown
Joe FitzPatrickUnknown
Rob GibsonUnknown
Christine GrahameUnknown
Fiona HyslopUnknown
Colin KeirUnknown
Bill KiddUnknown
Richard LochheadUnknown
Richard LyleUnknown
Kenny MacAskillUnknown
Angus MacDonaldUnknown
Gordon MacDonaldUnknown
Derek MackayUnknown
Mike MacKenzieUnknown
John MasonUnknown
Michael MathesonUnknown
Joan McAlpineUnknown
Mark McDonaldUnknown
Christina McKelvieUnknown
Aileen McLeodUnknown
Fiona McLeodUnknown
Alex NeilUnknown
Gil PatersonUnknown
Dennis RobertsonUnknown
Shona RobisonUnknown
Michael RussellUnknown
Alex SalmondUnknown
Stewart StevensonUnknown
Kevin StewartUnknown
Nicola SturgeonUnknown
Dave ThompsonUnknown
Jean UrquhartUnknown
Bill WalkerUnknown
Maureen WattUnknown
Paul WheelhouseUnknown
Humza YousafUnknown

Did not vote (16)

Source: the Scottish Parliament vote record.